Peer Review Process

Introduction

Indonesian Journal of Islamic Elementary Education (IJIEE) is a peer-reviewed, open-access journal that publishes original research articles, review articles, and case studies in the field of elementary education with an Islamic perspective. The journal aims to provide a platform for scholars, researchers, and students to share their research findings and insights on the latest developments in Islamic elementary education.

Peer review process

IJIEE uses a double anonymous peer review process to ensure the quality and rigor of its published articles. The peer review process is as follows:

1. Submission

Authors submit their articles to IJIEE through the journal's online submission system.

2. Preliminary evaluation

The editor-in-chief or an editorial board member will conduct a preliminary evaluation of the submitted articles to determine if they are suitable for peer review. Articles that are not suitable for peer review will be rejected without further review.

3. Peer review

Accepted articles will be assigned to two independent peer reviewers who are experts in the field of the article. Reviewers will evaluate the articles based on the following criteria:

• Originality and significance
• Methodology
• Results
• Discussion and conclusions
• Style and clarity

4. Decision

The editor-in-chief will make a decision on the basis of the peer review reports. Articles that are recommended for publication will be sent back to the authors for revision. Articles that are not recommended for publication will be rejected.

5. Revision

Authors of revised articles will have the opportunity to address the reviewers' comments. Revised articles will be re-reviewed by the same reviewers.

6. Final decision

The editor-in-chief will make a final decision on the basis of the revised articles and the re-review reports.

Appeals

Authors who disagree with the editor-in-chief's decision can appeal the decision to the editorial board. The editorial board will review the appeal and make a final decision.

Timeline

The peer review process typically takes 60-90 days.

Additional information

More information about the peer review process can be found on the journal's website.

Explanation

The peer review process is an important part of ensuring the quality and rigor of scientific publications. By following a rigorous peer review process, IJIEE is committed to publishing high-quality research that contributes to the advancement of knowledge in Islamic elementary education.